IAN ZELJAKReal Estate
en

Tools/Calculators/Rent vs. Buy

Rent vs. Buy Calculator

Type your rent and a home price. You see where each choice leaves you after the years you plan to stay, and the year buying pulls ahead. No sign up, and nothing you type is saved or sent anywhere.

Your numbers

$
$
%

$200,000

%
$
The assumptions
%
%
%

On money invested in place of a down payment.

%

As a percent of the home's price.

%

Insurance, HOA dues, upkeep.

%

An assumption, as a percent of the price. Agent compensation is negotiable.

After 7 years

Renting is ahead by $64,027

On these numbers buying pulls ahead in year 21. Before that, renting is ahead.

Buying: what you would have after selling$520,960
Renting: what your savings would be$584,987
Buying, first month's cost$7,406
Renting, first month's cost$4,520

What each choice leaves you with, year by year

$0$1.6M$3.1M051015202530
  • Buying
  • Renting
  • The year you expect to leave
YearHome valueIf you buyIf you rent
1$1,040,000$196,130$255,240
3$1,124,864$294,808$356,881
5$1,216,653$402,771$466,565
7$1,315,932$520,960$584,987
10$1,480,244$719,737$780,694
15$1,800,944$1,118,751$1,162,484
20$2,191,123$1,623,173$1,628,195
30$3,243,398$3,124,793$2,943,273

How to read this

  • Both paths start with the same cash: the down payment and closing costs of buying, $207,235. Each month, whoever pays less saves the difference.
  • Selling later is taken to cost 5% of the price. That covers agent compensation, which is negotiable, plus title, escrow and transfer taxes. Change it under More options.
  • Income tax is left out on both sides. Home prices, rents and returns never move in a straight line.

A comparison built on assumptions about the future. It is a way to think about the choice, not a prediction and not financial advice.

How the figures are worked out

How the comparison works

Both paths start with the same cash: the down payment and closing costs of buying. The renter keeps that cash invested. Each month, whoever pays less puts the difference into savings.

At the end of each year the buyer's side is the home sold at that year's value, less the cost of selling and the loan balance, plus any savings. The renter's side is their savings. The first year the buyer's side is larger is the break even year.

What owning costs here

Owning counts the loan payment, property tax, insurance, HOA dues, mortgage insurance and upkeep. Under Proposition 13 the taxed value of a California home rises at most 2% a year after you buy, so the calculator holds property tax growth to that.

Renting counts the rent, which rises each year, and renter's insurance.

The assumptions, and why to change them

The calculator starts with home prices rising 4% a year, rent rising 3%, savings earning 6%, other costs rising 3%, upkeep at 1% of the price a year and selling costing 5% of the price. These are starting points, not forecasts. Open The assumptions and try a slower market or a faster one. The answer often changes.

Figures behind this calculator were last checked on November 11, 2026.

Common Questions

How long do I need to stay for buying to come out ahead?

It depends on the price, the rent, the rate and how fast prices and rents move. Buying has large costs at the start and at the sale, so a short stay usually favors renting. The calculator shows the break even year for your numbers.

Is renting throwing money away?

No. Rent buys a place to live, and a renter who invests the down payment can build wealth too. Owning also has costs that build nothing: interest, property tax, insurance and upkeep. The fair comparison is what each choice leaves you with, which is what this calculator shows.

Does this include the tax benefits of owning?

No. Income tax is left out on both sides. For many households the standard deduction is larger than their mortgage interest and property tax, so the benefit is smaller than people expect. Ask a tax adviser about your own return.

Contact

Want Real Numbers for a Real Address?

Send the address or the price range. Ian will run it with you, with the lender's and the escrow company's figures in place of estimates.